Butterfinger Cookies!

Real quick tonight, I’d like to ask you for a favor! Next time you’re shopping on Amazon, would you mind using my link to get there? By navigating through my link, it is a completely FREE way for you to help support this blog! How? Amazon awards a small portion of your purchase to the “source” that brought you to their site — in that case…me! It’s totally FREE for you, and it significantly helps me be able to continue offering this online ministry! So thank you so much!

Alright: onto tonight’s delicious recipe!


Hey friends and Happy Wednesday!

It is a beautiful summer day here in NYC. I’ve got an installed, working air conditioner, and a potluck picnic on the horizon, so that means one thing…TIME TO BAKE SOME COOKIES!

Butterfinger Cookies by BeautyBeyondBones #dessert #treats #yummy #butterfinger #chocolate #peanutbutter #cookies #food #edrecovery

Yes! With the bars and clubs still closed, thanks to COVID19, picnicking has become this summer’s “hotspot.” And this Friday, my friends and I are doing a potluck picnic for dinner, so what better treat to bring than cookies?!

Butterfinger Cookies by BeautyBeyondBones #dessert #treats #yummy #butterfinger #chocolate #peanutbutter #cookies #food #edrecovery

Now, here’s the thing — I have been doing some baking recently. And yes – these cookies are not something that I can personally enjoy, because they do not adhere to the Specific Carb Diet, which I follow to keep my Ulcerative Colitis in remission.

BUT – sharing the joy of food with other people is one of my all time favorite things to do! Cooking is a love language, people. And don’t let anyone tell you otherwise!

Butterfinger Cookies by BeautyBeyondBones #dessert #treats #yummy #butterfinger #chocolate #peanutbutter #cookies #food #edrecovery

So – in addition to my fabulous Fiesta Shrimp and Avocado Salad, I’m going to making these OUTRAGEOUS cookies!

(And if you want me to highlight the salad recipe next week, let me know! It’s also a winner!)

But…without further ado…drumroll please…


Butterfinger Cookies by BeautyBeyondBones #dessert #treats #yummy #butterfinger #chocolate #peanutbutter #cookies #food #edrecovery

They’re chewy, they’re peanut buttery, they’ve got a kiss of toffee and chocolate. But best of all…they’re PACKED with BUTTERFINGERS!

I don’t know about you, but growing up, during Halloween, I had my radar set on one candy, and one candy only: Butterfingers.

Butterfinger Cookies by BeautyBeyondBones #dessert #treats #yummy #butterfinger #chocolate #peanutbutter #cookies #food #edrecovery

Sure, I loved Snickers. And Starburst were fine too.

But those butterfingers were like literal gold.

So I cannot imagine a better cookie than this childhood dream!

Butterfinger Cookies by BeautyBeyondBones #dessert #treats #yummy #butterfinger #chocolate #peanutbutter #cookies #food #edrecovery

Here’s what you need: (Makes 30 cookies!)

1/2 cup butter, softened
3/4 cup sugar
2/3 cup brown sugar, packed
2 eggs
1 cup peanut butter
1 1/2 tsp vanilla extract
1 cup all purpose flour
1/2 tsp baking soda
1/8 tsp baking powder
1/4 tsp salt
5 (2.1 oz) Butterfinger candy bars, chopped
2 (1.63 oz) bags peanut butter m&m’s

Baking Sheet
Parchment Paper
Measuring Cups/Spoons
Good Chef’s Knife (This is the one I use and love)

Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

In a large mixing bowl, cream the butter and sugars until perfectly smooth. Use either an electric mixer, or a whisk with lots of elbow grease. Add the eggs and beat until creamy.

Butterfinger Cookies by BeautyBeyondBones #dessert #treats #yummy #butterfinger #chocolate #peanutbutter #cookies #food #edrecovery

Then add in the peanut butter and vanilla, until well combined.

In a smaller mixing bowl, combine the flour, baking soda, baking powder, and salt. Add to the egg/PB/sugar mixture to combine. Stir in the candy bars and m&m’s.

Drop by heaping Tablespoons onto a parchment-lined baking sheet.

Butterfinger Cookies by BeautyBeyondBones #dessert #treats #yummy #butterfinger #chocolate #peanutbutter #cookies #food #edrecovery

Bake at 350 for 12 minutes, or until the cookies just start to turn brown. Do not over bake.

Let sit on the cookie sheet for a few minutes before transferring to a flat surface or wire rack to cool completely.

Butterfinger Cookies by BeautyBeyondBones #dessert #treats #yummy #butterfinger #chocolate #peanutbutter #cookies #food #edrecovery

Or, of course, eat one warm, preferably with a scoop of vanilla ice cream!

OK. SO. The verdict is in, and these cookies were A HIT AND A HALF! They were polished off, not a single one left!

Butterfinger Cookies by BeautyBeyondBones #dessert #treats #yummy #butterfinger #chocolate #peanutbutter #cookies #food #edrecovery

My friends were obsessed with the huge chunks of butterfingers, and of course, the peanut butter m&m’s! They thought the m&m’s were regular chocolate candies, so they were all so pleasantly surprised to find more peanut butter inside!

Butterfinger Cookies by BeautyBeyondBones #dessert #treats #yummy #butterfinger #chocolate #peanutbutter #cookies #food #edrecovery

And these were not wimpy cookies! They were big, and although they had so much “going on,” they were super soft and chewy!

Butterfinger Cookies by BeautyBeyondBones #dessert #treats #yummy #butterfinger #chocolate #peanutbutter #cookies #food #edrecovery

Want to know what dessert I brought for myself?

I brought my blueberry muffin bites, and oh my gosh, I was in cookie heaven, too!

If you have someone in your life you care about…make them these cookies. They will be such a happy camper!

Butterfinger Cookies by BeautyBeyondBones #dessert #treats #yummy #butterfinger #chocolate #peanutbutter #cookies #food #edrecovery

Until next time!

Happy baking!

Butterfinger Cookies by BeautyBeyondBones #dessert #treats #yummy #butterfinger #chocolate #peanutbutter #cookies #food #edrecovery

“This is what the Lord says to these bones: I will make breath enter you, and you will come to life.” Ez 37:5


A big thank you to my foundational sponsor, BetterHelp Online Therapy. I cannot begin to express how beneficial therapy was for my recovery from anorexia.  Speak with an online therapist. Or check out content about eating disorders from BetterHelp.


This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is img_2724-1024x683.jpg


[mc4wp_form id=”30616″]

Here was yesterday’s video! https://youtu.be/8pmp4ZI968A

MAGIC TOOTHPASTE? Yes! I am in love with this superior whitening toothpaste. It keeps my smile sparkling, without sensitivity or bleach! I made a website where you can directly order this miracle product! So if you want to give it a try, you can go ahead and grab a tube for yourself. I promise, your smile will thank you!Get a tube!

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is img_8166.jpg

I had so much fun going through the FabFitFun winter box — it’s filled with awesome products — from beauty, to fitness, fashion, skincare, home — all full size, valued at over $250, but sold for only $39.99 when you use my code “SANTABABY!”

Be sure to check out my affiliate, Audible. Listening to audiobooks while I cook is literally my new favorite thing. And just for you, they’re offering a Free 30-Day Trial Membership. And with this free membership, you’re going to get 2 free audiobooks! Literally. Free. It is the best deal ever. And if for some reason, you decide it’s not for you, you can cancel within those 30 days and it’s zero money out of your pocket, plus, you get to keep the 2 audiobooks. Soooo…it’s pretty much a no brainer. Plus, it’s a free and easy way to support this blog! So thank you!! 

Huge shoutout to my favorite: Ethos Spa Skin and Laser Center in Summit, New Jersey! Located just outside of NYC, this gorgeous medical spa keeps my skin healthy and bright! Stop in and treat yo’self! 🙂

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is E8C4AAF3-4F76-48BF-B1B7-09FCBB9F951C-150x150.jpg


@beauty.beyond.bones – Instagram




This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is patreon.png

For Podcast versions of my posts, please check out Patreon! It’s only $2 a month!! You make this blog possible 🙂

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is IMG_1288.jpg

And really quickly, I’ve had several questions concerning my Amazon link (amazon.com/shop/beautybeyondbones) — You do not need to buy one of my specific highlighted products on my page, in order for it to “credit” my account. Any purchases that you search or make from anywhere on Amazon, after first visiting my Amazon page, will credit this blog and help support this blog ministry. I am truly so grateful and appreciative to those of you wanting to do so! So thank you! Again, it is an absolutely free, and easy way for you to help keep this blog going!

68 responses to “Butterfinger Cookies!”

  1. I thought they were m&m’s too…but peanut butter one’s? 😂 🤣
    This time inside has been interesting, I started out putting on weight from lack of exercise but I found a way of gentle fasting that soon had the weight back past where I started…and still eat good stuff 😂 🤣

    • Thanks Mark! Yes! Peanut butter m&m’s!!! Glad you found something that works for you 🙂 Hugs and love xox

  2. The cookies look so delicious, Caralyn, how can you resist! Are they Diabetic friendly? Kidding, of course! 🥰

  3. Awesome! And yes to the shrimp and avocado salad. Please and thank you. 😉 BTW – does the SCD let you eat regular Butterfinger bars, or are some of it’s ingredients not allowed?

    • hi Kenneth! sadly, chocolate and sugar are not allowed on the SCD 🙁 but that’s okay! i don’t even miss it! hope you’re having a great night! Hugs and love xox

    • Thanks! Verdict’s in, and they were a hit!! glad you stopped by! Hugs and love xox

    • thank you Lydia!!! They were a real hit! i appreciate you stopping by! Hugs and love xox

  4. Followed you 2 yrs ago, I was away, but seriously you have grown a lot. It’s amazing. Keep up the good work.

    • Thank you so much! Wow you’re awesome! Great to “see” you again! Hugs and love xox

  5. Mmm these look so good!! We don’t have Butterfinger bars in the UK but I did try them once, yeeeeears ago when I worked in the States for a few weeks. Nom nommm!!

    Caz xx

    • Thanks so much Caz!! Nom nom for sure! I bet you could get some on amazon! Hugs and love xox

  6. Hey Igbo tech/STEM lady! When I’m not on my 9-5 I double as a travel consultant and a blogger in a multiniched sector. Travel, faith and lifestyle blog.


  7. Those look fabulous!! And are a pleasant reminder that it’s ok to splurge every now and then. 🙂 I love how you are able to find great recipes regardless of whether they adhere to your diet. I really enjoy cooking and baking for others, and these cookies are right up my alley! However I’m also trying to figure out more vegan options to accommodate my friends. You’ve given me TONS of great ideas over the years, so thank you!!

    • Thank you so much Yael!! Yes! I agree! Cooking is a love language! Hugs and love xox

  8. First of all congratulations on besting anorexia, you Look great, by the way! I have to make those Butterfinger cookies, they look so yummy, thanks for the recipe, and God bless 💝🤗

Leave a Reply to beautybeyondbonesCancel reply